CNN reports that the British medical journal Lancet and Facebook groups based mainly in Europe have joined the chorus of governments, AIDS-awareness and health agencies criticizing the pope for his gratuitous remarks that condoms do nothing to combat the spread of HIV, the virus which causes AIDS.
The pope's restatement of a long-held Vatican position sheds more public light on a major flaw in the official Catholic stance on human sexuality, pointed out by moral theologian Charles E. Curran and others: that by focusing too prominently on the physical structure of the act of reproduction, it prevents appropriate appreciation of other aspects of sexual acts, including their potential role in endangering public health and the best ways to avert that impact. Excerpts from the CNN report follow:
Critics took to the social networking site Facebook to voice their fury over Pope Benedict's remark that condoms do not prevent HIV.
Thousands have pledged to send the pontiff millions of condoms to protest the controversial comment he made to journalists as he flew to Cameroon last week.
"You can't resolve it with the distribution of condoms," the pope told reporters. "On the contrary, it increases the problem."
Pope Benedict XVI has made it clear he intends to uphold the traditional Catholic teaching on artificial contraception. The Vatican has long opposed the use of condoms and other forms of birth control and encourages sexual abstinence to fight the spread of the disease.
About a dozen Facebook groups have sprang up (sic), mostly from European countries, criticizing the pontiff.
The online campaign added another voice to a deluge of criticism, which includes the governments of France, Germany and Belgium. Aid agencies and other health organizations have also chimed in.
The Lancet, a British medical journal, urged the pope Saturday to issue a retraction for the "outrageous and wildly inaccurate" statement to journalists aboard his plane.
"When any influential person, be it a religious or political leader, makes a false scientific statement that could be devastating to the health of millions of people, they should retract or correct the public record," The Lancet said in an editorial.
"Anything less from Pope Benedict would be an immense disservice to the public and health advocates, including many thousands of Catholics, who work tirelessly to try and prevent the spread of HIV/AIDS worldwide."
Saturday, March 28, 2009
Thursday, March 26, 2009
Pope Needs to Fire Vatican's Archbishop Burke for Threatening U.S. Bishops

Archbishop Raymond Burke is at it again: trying to force every U.S. Catholic bishop to adopt his view that Catholic politicians who won't outlaw all abortions must be denied holy communion. Although the bishops declined to adopt his position when he was a member of their conference, he is now using his new job as a top Vatican official to tell them they were wrong and to say, in effect, "my way or the highway."
At first he was content to impose the policy in LaCrosse, WI, where he was archbishop from 1995 to 2003. But when he was made archbishop of St. Louis in 2004, Burke upped the ante--by raising the issue against the presidential candidacy of John Kerry.
Also that year, Burke led a minority group of bishops who wanted to make the policy mandatory for all U.S. bishops. But the bishops did not agree and decided instead that each bishop would have the final say in his own diocese.
Not happy with that outcome, Burke went on to tell Catholics that if they voted for a pro-choice candidate, they were committing grave sin and they could not receive communion either.
Burke also meddled in the 2008 presidential campaign, again admonishing Catholics that they could not vote for a pro-choice candidate and again pressing other bishops to extend his ban to other Catholic politicians. Burke gained few converts in either audience.
In June of 2008 many in the United States breathed a sigh of relief at the news Burke had been named to head the Apostolic Signatura, also known as the Vatican's supreme court. But others expressed concern that with his quirky way of applying canon law to reception of communion, Burke could do more damage there. Those fears, it turns out, were well founded.
Speaking from Rome in January Burke condemned the election of pro-choice candidate Obama and placed much of the blame on a U.S. bishops' election guide that he considered lukewarm in opposing abortion.
Now we learn from the National Catholic Reporter and other media outlets that Burke is aiding an anti-abortion terrorist who wants the Vatican to remove any U.S. bishops will not deny communion to pro-choice Catholic politicians.
Burke made his remarks in a videotaped interview with Randall Terry, the former head of Operation Rescue, who was arrested more than 40 times for illegal anti-abortion activities. Terry is now a Burke disciple. Terry has been campaigning to have Rome remove U.S. bishops who will not take Burke's position on communion.
Burke said he "would encourage the faithful when they are scandalized by the giving of Holy Communion to persons are publicly and obstinately in sin, that they go to their pastors, whether it’s their parish priest or to their bishop, to insist that this scandal stop."
Contrary to the U.S. bishops, Burke also said it is the responsibility of all who distribute communion--whether bishops, priests or lay ministers--to identify such sinners and refuse them communion.
Burke soon apologized to "my brother bishops" after Terry played the videotape March 25th at the National Press Club. But he did not withdraw his criticism, his advice to parishioners, or his instructions to ministers of communion.
It is quite evident that Burke has no intention of abiding by the U.S. bishops' ruling that denying communion to politicians is a decision the only the local bishop can make. The only way to stop him from misusing his Vatican office to oppose the bishops' policy is to remove him from office.
He needs to be removed because his office gives him no authority to undermine the bishops on this issue.
He needs to be removed because he arrogates to himself the authority to judge that an individual Catholic politician "is publicly and obstinately in grave sin," simply because that politician is not convinced that outlawing abortion is the best way to protect human life in utero.
In taking that absolutist position, Burke goes well beyond Rome's official guidance, as voiced for example in these words of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger: "As John Paul II has taught in his Encyclical Letter Evangelium vitae regarding the situation in which it is not possible to overturn or completely repeal a law allowing abortion which is already in force or coming up for a vote, 'an elected official, whose absolute personal opposition to procured abortion was well known, could licitly support proposals aimed at limiting the harm done by such a law and at lessening its negative consequences at the level of general opinion and public morality.'"
That is in fact what most pro-choice Catholic politicians are trying to accomplish. Granting due weight to their oaths of office, the Supreme Court's ruling in Roe v. Wade, and the majority sentiment of the voters, they recognize that current U.S. law cannot be overturned and seek more realistic ways to reduce the number of abortions. That was also the position of pro-life Catholics who nonetheless supported Barack Obama.
For Burke and other ultraconservative bishops to berate and condemn them for that is unconscionable. For the pope to allow Burke to use his Vatican office as a new club to attack politicians and bishops who are following papal teaching is even worse. That is particularly so when the pope himself, on his last visit to the United States, made no issue whatsoever of pro-choice Catholic politicians who received communion at various papal masses.
Such a canon-law maverick has no business occupying the church's highest judicial office short of the papacy. Burke must go!
Wednesday, March 25, 2009
G0P: "Like an Arsonist Who Complains That the Fire Department Is Wasting Water"
CNN Political Contributor Paul Begala says it takes amazing chutzpah for conservative critics to be complaining that President Obama is trying to do too much at once and spending too much to do it, given that every major problem he's attacking was created or exacerbated by eight years of conservative technical stupidity, reckless deficit spending, regulatory malfeasance and repeated mismanagement of the federal government:
Obama inherited an ungodly mess: a $1.2 trillion deficit, an economy that was careening from recession into depression, a collapse in effective demand, the disintegration of the real estate market and a financial meltdown that spanned the globe and brought multibillion-dollar institutions to their knees. That's not to mention Iraq, Afghanistan, Iran, North Korea and the Mexican drug war.
If this were "Sesame Street," the announcer would be saying, "This program brought to you by the letters G, O and P." None of the crises the president is addressing were of his creation. All of them were created or worsened by the Republicans who ran the House of Representatives, Senate and White House for years.
And so the American people turned to Obama to bring change -- and change he has brought. He's moving on all fronts: addressing the housing foreclosure crisis, the banking crisis, the unemployment crisis. Did I mention that all of these crises were courtesy of the Republicans who ran this country for years? Good.
Now the Republicans have what we Texans call the chutzpah to criticize Obama for doing too much. Maybe, just maybe, he wouldn't have to be fixing so many problems if the Republicans hadn't created so many problems.
The Republicans are like an arsonist who complains that the fire department is wasting water. Obama is trying to handle an immediate crisis while also laying the foundation for long-term growth. The Republicans are doing neither. They have no plan to stop the loss of jobs or to get capital markets functioning properly -- and they certainly have no plans for health care, education or energy, which are the keys to both long-term economic growth and long-term deficit reduction.
All the energy -- indeed all debate -- is on the progressive side of the aisle. The Obama administration's only intellectual challengers are on the left, where economist and New York Times columnist Paul Krugman and others are offering a vigorous critique and proposing alternative solutions. But where are the Republicans? Doing nothing but complaining. Unless and until they do offer an alternative, they really have no right to whine about the president. For now at least, GOP stands for "Got 0 Plans."
Obama inherited an ungodly mess: a $1.2 trillion deficit, an economy that was careening from recession into depression, a collapse in effective demand, the disintegration of the real estate market and a financial meltdown that spanned the globe and brought multibillion-dollar institutions to their knees. That's not to mention Iraq, Afghanistan, Iran, North Korea and the Mexican drug war.
If this were "Sesame Street," the announcer would be saying, "This program brought to you by the letters G, O and P." None of the crises the president is addressing were of his creation. All of them were created or worsened by the Republicans who ran the House of Representatives, Senate and White House for years.
And so the American people turned to Obama to bring change -- and change he has brought. He's moving on all fronts: addressing the housing foreclosure crisis, the banking crisis, the unemployment crisis. Did I mention that all of these crises were courtesy of the Republicans who ran this country for years? Good.
Now the Republicans have what we Texans call the chutzpah to criticize Obama for doing too much. Maybe, just maybe, he wouldn't have to be fixing so many problems if the Republicans hadn't created so many problems.
The Republicans are like an arsonist who complains that the fire department is wasting water. Obama is trying to handle an immediate crisis while also laying the foundation for long-term growth. The Republicans are doing neither. They have no plan to stop the loss of jobs or to get capital markets functioning properly -- and they certainly have no plans for health care, education or energy, which are the keys to both long-term economic growth and long-term deficit reduction.
All the energy -- indeed all debate -- is on the progressive side of the aisle. The Obama administration's only intellectual challengers are on the left, where economist and New York Times columnist Paul Krugman and others are offering a vigorous critique and proposing alternative solutions. But where are the Republicans? Doing nothing but complaining. Unless and until they do offer an alternative, they really have no right to whine about the president. For now at least, GOP stands for "Got 0 Plans."
Angry at $165 Million in AIG Bonuses? Get Angrier at $13 Billion Goldman Got from AIG
Houston Chronicle Business Columnist Loren Steffy says the public's anger over paying for AIG's $165 million in bonuses is understandable, but as "one one-millionth of the total amount we've pumped into the foundering insurance shop," the bonus boondoggle pales in comparison to the $13 billion in bailout funds that AIG funneled to Goldman Sachs.
The $13 billion was used to pay swap contracts that Goldman bought from AIG--meaning that AIG irresponsibly sold $13 billion more insurance on other deals than it had the resources to cover. Thus taxpayer funds were used simultaneously to relieve AIG of a debt and make creditor Goldman whole.
The move also might allow Goldman, although claiming that the $13 billion was "immaterial," to return $10 billion in TARP bailout funds after finding the government controls that came with it too confining. That way Goldman gets even more taxpayer billions through AIG, but with no government regulation whatsoever.
As Steffy suggests, the public and politicians need to direct their anger at Goldman's really big ripoff, compared to which the AIG bonuses are truly chump change.
The $13 billion was used to pay swap contracts that Goldman bought from AIG--meaning that AIG irresponsibly sold $13 billion more insurance on other deals than it had the resources to cover. Thus taxpayer funds were used simultaneously to relieve AIG of a debt and make creditor Goldman whole.
The move also might allow Goldman, although claiming that the $13 billion was "immaterial," to return $10 billion in TARP bailout funds after finding the government controls that came with it too confining. That way Goldman gets even more taxpayer billions through AIG, but with no government regulation whatsoever.
As Steffy suggests, the public and politicians need to direct their anger at Goldman's really big ripoff, compared to which the AIG bonuses are truly chump change.
Monday, March 23, 2009
Community Reinvestment Act Did Not Cause Mortgage or Credit Crises, Data Show
Relaxing with friends this weekend in the Texas hill country, I discovered that the bogus argument that loans to poor people caused the mortgage and credit crises--debunked here last October--is still making the rounds. Getting back to my regular reading this morning, I came upon the following editorial in the March 20th print edition of the National Catholic Reporter (posted online March 13th). It explains quite succinctly what other media sources have said repeatedly for several months: the Carter-era Community Reinvestment Act, which encouraged banks to lend in neighborhoods where they do business, was responsible for less than 10% of the subprime loans. The blame-worthy lenders and borrowers were those involved in the 90% of the subprime loans that were not made to the poor.
Each week, in our depressed economy, another 40,000 U.S. homeowners face foreclosure (see story, Page 1). So who is to blame for the implosion of the U.S. housing market, the engine that drove our false sense of prosperity over the past decade?
It's the poor. They, with a little help from the government, did it to themselves.
That, at least, is the emerging consensus of free marketer pundits who dare not place blame where it truly belongs: on the false god of a freewheeling and virtually unregulated subprime mortgage marketplace.
The villain in this fictitious but ideologically convenient tale is something called the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), a Carter-era initiative that put some mild requirements on federally insured depository institutions (banks and thrifts) to lend in neighborhoods where they do business.
"Beginning with the Community Reinvestment Act of 1977, the political system helped create this mess," Michael Novak, a one-time supporter of CRA and other community-based efforts to support neighborhoods, wrote in First Things earlier this year. Novak argued that government programs like CRA ultimately forced lenders to make loans to people who could not afford them, resulting in a worldwide economic meltdown of Depression-era proportions.
Similar sentiments have been voiced by Lawrence Kudlow of CNBC, Neil Cavuto of FOX News (who placed the blame on banks that lent to "minorities and risky folks"), syndicated columnists Charles Krauthammer and George Will, and many others over the past few months.
The central problem with this argument is that there is no data, absolutely none, tying CRA in any significant way to subprime lending practices now fueling the foreclosure crisis.
Former Federal Reserve Gov. Randall Kroszner, speaking late last year, used actual facts, data even, to explain the situation.
More than half of subprime loans went to middle-class or higher-income borrowers, while fewer than 6 percent of loans made by CRA-covered lenders to low-income borrowers in recent years were of the subprime variety, said Kroszner.
Based on research (imagine that!), Kroszner concluded, "The loans that are the focus of the CRA represent a very small portion of the subprime lending market, casting considerable doubt on the potential contribution that the law could have made to the subprime mortgage crisis."
Meanwhile, Comptroller of the Currency John Dugan, a Bush appointee, noted, "CRA is not the culprit behind the subprime mortgage lending abuses or the broader credit quality issues in the marketplace. Indeed, the lenders most prominently associated with subprime mortgage lending abuses and high rates of foreclosure are lenders not subject to CRA."
For 30-plus years, CRA has been a modest but useful tool in providing capital and credit to individuals and community-based organizations trying to improve neighborhoods through homeownership, affordable rental housing and economic development programs.
It is part of the solution, not a cause of the problem.
Each week, in our depressed economy, another 40,000 U.S. homeowners face foreclosure (see story, Page 1). So who is to blame for the implosion of the U.S. housing market, the engine that drove our false sense of prosperity over the past decade?
It's the poor. They, with a little help from the government, did it to themselves.
That, at least, is the emerging consensus of free marketer pundits who dare not place blame where it truly belongs: on the false god of a freewheeling and virtually unregulated subprime mortgage marketplace.
The villain in this fictitious but ideologically convenient tale is something called the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), a Carter-era initiative that put some mild requirements on federally insured depository institutions (banks and thrifts) to lend in neighborhoods where they do business.
"Beginning with the Community Reinvestment Act of 1977, the political system helped create this mess," Michael Novak, a one-time supporter of CRA and other community-based efforts to support neighborhoods, wrote in First Things earlier this year. Novak argued that government programs like CRA ultimately forced lenders to make loans to people who could not afford them, resulting in a worldwide economic meltdown of Depression-era proportions.
Similar sentiments have been voiced by Lawrence Kudlow of CNBC, Neil Cavuto of FOX News (who placed the blame on banks that lent to "minorities and risky folks"), syndicated columnists Charles Krauthammer and George Will, and many others over the past few months.
The central problem with this argument is that there is no data, absolutely none, tying CRA in any significant way to subprime lending practices now fueling the foreclosure crisis.
Former Federal Reserve Gov. Randall Kroszner, speaking late last year, used actual facts, data even, to explain the situation.
More than half of subprime loans went to middle-class or higher-income borrowers, while fewer than 6 percent of loans made by CRA-covered lenders to low-income borrowers in recent years were of the subprime variety, said Kroszner.
Based on research (imagine that!), Kroszner concluded, "The loans that are the focus of the CRA represent a very small portion of the subprime lending market, casting considerable doubt on the potential contribution that the law could have made to the subprime mortgage crisis."
Meanwhile, Comptroller of the Currency John Dugan, a Bush appointee, noted, "CRA is not the culprit behind the subprime mortgage lending abuses or the broader credit quality issues in the marketplace. Indeed, the lenders most prominently associated with subprime mortgage lending abuses and high rates of foreclosure are lenders not subject to CRA."
For 30-plus years, CRA has been a modest but useful tool in providing capital and credit to individuals and community-based organizations trying to improve neighborhoods through homeownership, affordable rental housing and economic development programs.
It is part of the solution, not a cause of the problem.
Thursday, March 19, 2009
2nd Amendment Ruling Shooting Blanks, So Far, New York Times Correspondent Says
In a February posting I applauded the lack of success to date of the movement to allow guns on college campuses and provided links to previous postings on that subject and on the Supreme Court's mistaken conclusion nine months ago that the U.S. Constitution's 2nd Amendment codified an individual right to kill.
I draw additional encouragement from a March 17th report by New York Times Supreme Court Correspondent Adam Liptak that in terms of overturning gun-control laws, the Heller decision is "firing blanks."
Liptak reports that in deciding more than 80 cases after the Supreme Court's decision, lower federal courts have, in the words of Adam Winkler, a University of California law professor, “not invalidated a single gun control law on the basis of the Second Amendment since Heller.”
Liptak's summary of the laws the courts have upheld is impressive: "The courts have upheld federal laws banning gun ownership by people convicted of felonies and some misdemeanors, by illegal immigrants and by drug addicts. They have upheld laws banning machine guns and sawed-off shotguns. They have upheld laws making it illegal to carry guns near schools or in post offices. And they have upheld laws concerning concealed and unregistered weapons."
In a not unmerited dig against gun advocates, Winkler wrote in the UCLA Law Review “So far, the only real change from Heller is that gun owners have to pay higher legal fees to find out that they lose.” This, of course, supports the view of critics right after the Heller decision that it had left so many legal loose ends that it would prove a bottomless resource for litigators.
Liptak observes that one question the Supreme Court left open is whether the 2nd Amendment, as interpreted in Heller, also applies to the states. Most legal scholars suspect that it does, but Liptak believes that state courts probably have to follow older decisions until the Supreme Court rules on that issue specifically.
Liptak concludes with this sage advice from Sanford Levinson, a law professor at the University of Texas: “My own bet is that Heller will more likely than not turn out to be of no significance to anyone but constitutional theorists.”
I draw additional encouragement from a March 17th report by New York Times Supreme Court Correspondent Adam Liptak that in terms of overturning gun-control laws, the Heller decision is "firing blanks."
Liptak reports that in deciding more than 80 cases after the Supreme Court's decision, lower federal courts have, in the words of Adam Winkler, a University of California law professor, “not invalidated a single gun control law on the basis of the Second Amendment since Heller.”
Liptak's summary of the laws the courts have upheld is impressive: "The courts have upheld federal laws banning gun ownership by people convicted of felonies and some misdemeanors, by illegal immigrants and by drug addicts. They have upheld laws banning machine guns and sawed-off shotguns. They have upheld laws making it illegal to carry guns near schools or in post offices. And they have upheld laws concerning concealed and unregistered weapons."
In a not unmerited dig against gun advocates, Winkler wrote in the UCLA Law Review “So far, the only real change from Heller is that gun owners have to pay higher legal fees to find out that they lose.” This, of course, supports the view of critics right after the Heller decision that it had left so many legal loose ends that it would prove a bottomless resource for litigators.
Liptak observes that one question the Supreme Court left open is whether the 2nd Amendment, as interpreted in Heller, also applies to the states. Most legal scholars suspect that it does, but Liptak believes that state courts probably have to follow older decisions until the Supreme Court rules on that issue specifically.
Liptak concludes with this sage advice from Sanford Levinson, a law professor at the University of Texas: “My own bet is that Heller will more likely than not turn out to be of no significance to anyone but constitutional theorists.”
Richardson Signs Death Penalty Repeal, after Visiting Inmates, Officers, Victims & Church
The Santa Fe New Mexican reports that last night, with the support of the Catholic Church and considerable personal anxiety, Gov. Bill Richardson signed a bill that repealed the death penalty in New Mexico.
The article says Richardson reached his decision only after a very gut-wrenching process, during which he went to Mass, visited death row and the state's 'death house,' made eye contact with one death-row inmate and an inmate awaiting trial for murdering a deputy, and listened personally to corrections officials and the families of two murder victims.
Richardson said he was still wrestling with whether he's for or against the death penalty and with whether he made the right decision.
But in signing the bill he added: "Regardless of my personal opinion about the death penalty, I do not have confidence in the criminal justice system as it currently operates to be the final arbiter when it comes to who lives and who dies for their crime. If the state is going to undertake this awesome responsibility, the system to impose this ultimate penalty must be perfect and can never be wrong."
He said after visiting death row, "I came to the conclusion that those cells may be worse than death" and that life without parole is "a just punishment."
The Catholic Church has long favored abolition of the death penalty everywhere, in part for the reasons Richardson mentioned and also because it may deprive those executed of the opportunity to repent and victims' loved ones of time to foresake vengence and forgive. Beside Richardson when he signed the bill was Bishop Ricardo Ramirez of Las Cruces. The bishop noted that Archbishop Michael Sheehan of Santa Fe also favored the repeal but currently was out of the country.
The article says Richardson reached his decision only after a very gut-wrenching process, during which he went to Mass, visited death row and the state's 'death house,' made eye contact with one death-row inmate and an inmate awaiting trial for murdering a deputy, and listened personally to corrections officials and the families of two murder victims.
Richardson said he was still wrestling with whether he's for or against the death penalty and with whether he made the right decision.
But in signing the bill he added: "Regardless of my personal opinion about the death penalty, I do not have confidence in the criminal justice system as it currently operates to be the final arbiter when it comes to who lives and who dies for their crime. If the state is going to undertake this awesome responsibility, the system to impose this ultimate penalty must be perfect and can never be wrong."
He said after visiting death row, "I came to the conclusion that those cells may be worse than death" and that life without parole is "a just punishment."
The Catholic Church has long favored abolition of the death penalty everywhere, in part for the reasons Richardson mentioned and also because it may deprive those executed of the opportunity to repent and victims' loved ones of time to foresake vengence and forgive. Beside Richardson when he signed the bill was Bishop Ricardo Ramirez of Las Cruces. The bishop noted that Archbishop Michael Sheehan of Santa Fe also favored the repeal but currently was out of the country.
Wednesday, March 18, 2009
Will the New English Liturgy Be Seen as Another Papal Departure from Vatican II?
Google News has a link to an Associated Press article and others reporting that premature use in South Africa of a new English liturgy based on a more slavishly literal translation of Rome's official Latin is causing local Catholics and even one bishop to question if it is yet another papal effort to undo Vatican II.
The negative reactions echo concerns I raised in the first posting on this blog in July of 2006, A Better Way to Change Catholic Liturgical Language, which analyzed the changes planned for the U.S. English liturgy and found most of them seriously deficient and likely to cause unnecessary grief for the people in the pews. My chief suggestions were that in changing liturgical language, the church should do two things to assist believers who found the new language jarring or even unacceptable: (1) officially condone several settings where the prior language could be retained, so that those who favored it could still enjoy it; and (2) officially promote and sponsor other specific locations where newer versions of the liturgy could be crafted, celebrated, tested by the local community and, if fruitful, offered to the larger church for official adoption.
Several paragraphs from the AP article follow:
A new translation of the Roman Catholic Mass that is to be introduced worldwide in a few years is getting an accidental trial run in South Africa, where some parishioners are complaining it's too hard to understand.
The controversy comes as Pope Benedict XVI travels Tuesday to Cameroon on his first papal pilgrimage to the continent that has the fastest growing congregation of Catholics.
Critics say the new, more literal word-for-word translation is part of an attempt to roll back the progress made decades ago when the church halted its insistence on Latin.
In a misunderstanding, some South African church leaders started using the new version prematurely in some parishes, even though the English-language prayers won't be approved for global use for at least a couple of years. But instead of pulling back in the face of their mistake, they are continuing to use the liturgy.
Distribution of the prayers has fueled debate over whether the new translation — meant to more closely follow the original Latin text — will help deepen parishioners' prayer life or alienate them from the church.
"I think the church has been very lucky that the South Africans jumped the gun because it's showing the Vatican that there is going to be a worldwide problem when these new translations are put into effect," said Thomas Reese, a Jesuit priest and senior fellow at the Woodstock Theological Center at Georgetown University.
"Once again the Vatican isn't listening to the critics, and we're going to have another major embarrassment to the pope when these translations are put into effect and are forced on the people in the pews," he said.
The Rev. Efrem Tresoldi warned in The Southern Cross, a regional Catholic weekly: "I've heard it said that younger people are leaving the Church because, among other things, the language used in our liturgy sounds foreign to them. I think this new version of the order of the Mass is even more alienating."
In an article in The Southern Cross, Bishop Kevin Dowling agreed.
"I am concerned that this latest decision from the Vatican may be interpreted as another example of what is perceived to be a systematic and well-managed dismantling of the vision, theology and ecclesiology of Vatican II."
The Rev. Russell Pollitt also questioned whether nonnative English speakers in South Africa, where there are 11 official languages, would understand the more abstract concepts.
"The new text seems almost to imply that there is something inherently holy about Latin and inherently unholy about proper English," English Professor Colin Gardner said.
The negative reactions echo concerns I raised in the first posting on this blog in July of 2006, A Better Way to Change Catholic Liturgical Language, which analyzed the changes planned for the U.S. English liturgy and found most of them seriously deficient and likely to cause unnecessary grief for the people in the pews. My chief suggestions were that in changing liturgical language, the church should do two things to assist believers who found the new language jarring or even unacceptable: (1) officially condone several settings where the prior language could be retained, so that those who favored it could still enjoy it; and (2) officially promote and sponsor other specific locations where newer versions of the liturgy could be crafted, celebrated, tested by the local community and, if fruitful, offered to the larger church for official adoption.
Several paragraphs from the AP article follow:
A new translation of the Roman Catholic Mass that is to be introduced worldwide in a few years is getting an accidental trial run in South Africa, where some parishioners are complaining it's too hard to understand.
The controversy comes as Pope Benedict XVI travels Tuesday to Cameroon on his first papal pilgrimage to the continent that has the fastest growing congregation of Catholics.
Critics say the new, more literal word-for-word translation is part of an attempt to roll back the progress made decades ago when the church halted its insistence on Latin.
In a misunderstanding, some South African church leaders started using the new version prematurely in some parishes, even though the English-language prayers won't be approved for global use for at least a couple of years. But instead of pulling back in the face of their mistake, they are continuing to use the liturgy.
Distribution of the prayers has fueled debate over whether the new translation — meant to more closely follow the original Latin text — will help deepen parishioners' prayer life or alienate them from the church.
"I think the church has been very lucky that the South Africans jumped the gun because it's showing the Vatican that there is going to be a worldwide problem when these new translations are put into effect," said Thomas Reese, a Jesuit priest and senior fellow at the Woodstock Theological Center at Georgetown University.
"Once again the Vatican isn't listening to the critics, and we're going to have another major embarrassment to the pope when these translations are put into effect and are forced on the people in the pews," he said.
The Rev. Efrem Tresoldi warned in The Southern Cross, a regional Catholic weekly: "I've heard it said that younger people are leaving the Church because, among other things, the language used in our liturgy sounds foreign to them. I think this new version of the order of the Mass is even more alienating."
In an article in The Southern Cross, Bishop Kevin Dowling agreed.
"I am concerned that this latest decision from the Vatican may be interpreted as another example of what is perceived to be a systematic and well-managed dismantling of the vision, theology and ecclesiology of Vatican II."
The Rev. Russell Pollitt also questioned whether nonnative English speakers in South Africa, where there are 11 official languages, would understand the more abstract concepts.
"The new text seems almost to imply that there is something inherently holy about Latin and inherently unholy about proper English," English Professor Colin Gardner said.
Tuesday, March 17, 2009
How Pope Benedict XVI Can Avoid "becoming a sort of Dali Lama in papal dress"
The National Catholic Reporter has a translation of a very insightful March 14th commentary on the current crisis of authority in the Catholic Church by Italian political scientist and philosopher Ernesto Galli della Loggia, a lay professor at the University of San Raffaele in Milan. NCR says Della Loggia is widely regarded as one of Italy’s foremost commentators on Catholic affairs, despite being a self-professed nonbeliever himself.
Speaking of the pastoral letter Benedict XVI sent to the world's bishops to address negative reactions to his leadership among Catholics, Jews and secular Europeans, Della Loggia writes: "The letter and its contents betray feelings of anxiety and disappointment which, in reality, bring something much more important into view: a basic crisis of authority that today is felt at the very top of the church.
"Contradictions accumulated over the last half-century are coming to a head with regard to the role of the pope, which has undergone a profound historical transformation. That transformation has two principal causes, with which popes have had to come to terms: the advent of television, and the Second Vatican Council (1962-65)."
Della Loggia recalls how John XXIII, in leading the church and convoking the council, realized the importance of communicating through television and used it sagely to cultivate his media persona as "good Pope John." Unfortunately, della Loggia suggests, this tended over time to make the pope dependent on the approval of the public who watched TV, and accountable to their sense of political correctness. Always craving favorable media attention, the pope runs "the risk of becoming a sort of Dali Lama in papal dress."
Coupled with that, della Loggia adds, was Vatican II's role both in bringing liberal and conservative political parties to light within Catholicism and in fueling their competing positions going forward. Both sides realized the importance of using the media to press their positions publicly on the pope and to criticize him publicly when he departs from their vision of what the church is, what positions it should take, how it should be operated, and the like.
Della Loggia concludes that having to account to the public and these Catholic parties can tend to rob the pope of the spiritual independence he used to have and can, as it appeared to in the current controversy, leave him "painfully, irrevocably alone."
I think della Loggia's analysis is accurate for the most part. I would modify it, however, by arguing that despite John Paul II's superior skill at manipulating the media to endear himself to the public and the faithful, the pope never had as much spiritual independence as della Loggia suggests, or as the First Vatican Council (1869-1870) wanted him to have.
Moreover, one of the accomplishments of Vatican II, one which may yet prove enduring, is that it situated the authority of the pope in the context of other authorities--especially the pope and the bishops teaching together, and all of them on concert with carefully schooled theologians and devoted lay people.
Despite the conservative-liberal disagreement, the bishops, theologians and lay experts at the Council achieved consensus on an amazing variety of issues. The pope avoids becoming "a Dali Lama in papal dress" by repeatedly upholding that consensus, and by insisting that any changes to it are made only after a new consensus is worked for and achieved.
And that isn't restricted to changes conservatives want or changes liberals want or changes desired by dialogue partners like Jews and Muslims and non-believers. It also includes changes theologians want and changes the pope himself favors. He remains relevant by promoting dialogue and mutual persuasion, and by insisting that no parties of lesser authority than the Second Vatican Council get their way until they can forge a new consensus similar in scope, breadth, depth and weight. Until then, those individual wants are proposals, having no official prominence until enough believers find them persuasive.
This has been my issue with all of the popes since Paul VI issued Humanae vitae in 1968 and began what is now a 40-year papal attempt to make Vatican II say things it never said and support interpretations of Catholic church history which it never endorsed.
Benedict XVI still has a chance to become the first post-Vatican II pope to resume the models of church teaching and church governance that Vatican II favored. Given his track record as Cardinal Ratzinger and pope, I do not hold my breath. But who knows what surprises the Spirit who inspired the Council may have in store?
Speaking of the pastoral letter Benedict XVI sent to the world's bishops to address negative reactions to his leadership among Catholics, Jews and secular Europeans, Della Loggia writes: "The letter and its contents betray feelings of anxiety and disappointment which, in reality, bring something much more important into view: a basic crisis of authority that today is felt at the very top of the church.
"Contradictions accumulated over the last half-century are coming to a head with regard to the role of the pope, which has undergone a profound historical transformation. That transformation has two principal causes, with which popes have had to come to terms: the advent of television, and the Second Vatican Council (1962-65)."
Della Loggia recalls how John XXIII, in leading the church and convoking the council, realized the importance of communicating through television and used it sagely to cultivate his media persona as "good Pope John." Unfortunately, della Loggia suggests, this tended over time to make the pope dependent on the approval of the public who watched TV, and accountable to their sense of political correctness. Always craving favorable media attention, the pope runs "the risk of becoming a sort of Dali Lama in papal dress."
Coupled with that, della Loggia adds, was Vatican II's role both in bringing liberal and conservative political parties to light within Catholicism and in fueling their competing positions going forward. Both sides realized the importance of using the media to press their positions publicly on the pope and to criticize him publicly when he departs from their vision of what the church is, what positions it should take, how it should be operated, and the like.
Della Loggia concludes that having to account to the public and these Catholic parties can tend to rob the pope of the spiritual independence he used to have and can, as it appeared to in the current controversy, leave him "painfully, irrevocably alone."
I think della Loggia's analysis is accurate for the most part. I would modify it, however, by arguing that despite John Paul II's superior skill at manipulating the media to endear himself to the public and the faithful, the pope never had as much spiritual independence as della Loggia suggests, or as the First Vatican Council (1869-1870) wanted him to have.
Moreover, one of the accomplishments of Vatican II, one which may yet prove enduring, is that it situated the authority of the pope in the context of other authorities--especially the pope and the bishops teaching together, and all of them on concert with carefully schooled theologians and devoted lay people.
Despite the conservative-liberal disagreement, the bishops, theologians and lay experts at the Council achieved consensus on an amazing variety of issues. The pope avoids becoming "a Dali Lama in papal dress" by repeatedly upholding that consensus, and by insisting that any changes to it are made only after a new consensus is worked for and achieved.
And that isn't restricted to changes conservatives want or changes liberals want or changes desired by dialogue partners like Jews and Muslims and non-believers. It also includes changes theologians want and changes the pope himself favors. He remains relevant by promoting dialogue and mutual persuasion, and by insisting that no parties of lesser authority than the Second Vatican Council get their way until they can forge a new consensus similar in scope, breadth, depth and weight. Until then, those individual wants are proposals, having no official prominence until enough believers find them persuasive.
This has been my issue with all of the popes since Paul VI issued Humanae vitae in 1968 and began what is now a 40-year papal attempt to make Vatican II say things it never said and support interpretations of Catholic church history which it never endorsed.
Benedict XVI still has a chance to become the first post-Vatican II pope to resume the models of church teaching and church governance that Vatican II favored. Given his track record as Cardinal Ratzinger and pope, I do not hold my breath. But who knows what surprises the Spirit who inspired the Council may have in store?
Thursday, March 12, 2009
Benedict Reforms Vatican to Head Off New Mistakes, Yet Still Waffles on Vatican II
Multiple news outlets are reporting that on March 10th Pope Benedict XVI issued a pastoral letter to all Catholic bishops, apologizing for the controversy he caused by lifting the excommunication of a Holocaust-denying bishop and changing some Vatican structures and procedures to reduce the chances of such mistakes in the future. However, in defending his attempts to reconcile Catholic ultraconservatives with the church, the pope continued to voice the same kind of tepid support for Vatican II that caused such a hostile response from Catholic progressives in the first place.
Spiegel Online International offered this summary of the pope's letter: "Pope Benedict XVI has made a rare admission of a 'mishap' in the Vatican's handling of Holocaust denier Bishop Richard Williamson. A cardinal partly to blame for the debacle has been stripped of his power, and the pope says the Vatican ought to make better use of the Internet--to inform itself about crises more quickly."
The article continued: "The Ecclesia Dei Pontifical Commission, which was responsible for the Richard Williamson case, is being dissolved and will be merged with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith... As a result, Cardinal DarÃo Castrillón Hoyos, who triggered the Williamson debacle in mid-January, has been deprived of his power and, at almost 80, will slip into a well-earned retirement. 'Now that was quite a crash,' a prelate who witnessed the events said on Wednesday afternoon "
The article also noted that, in a substantive effort to improve communications within the Vatican bureaucracy, the pope appeared to be specifically directing the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith to use a regular Wednesday meeting of Vatican department heads to ensure that all of them were on the same page on issues of major significance.
The Vatican issued official translations of the pope's letter this morning. The English translation confirms the points Spiegel emphasized. The pope acknowledges that the nearly simultaneous lifting of the excommunications and Bishop Williamson's reiteration of his Holocaust denial "caused, both within and beyond the Catholic Church, a discussion more heated than any we have seen for a long time." He said it was "An unforeseen mishap for me...that the Williamson case came on top of the remission of the excommunication."
The pope said he did not intend lifting the excommunications of four traditionalist bishops to be seen as turning back the clock on Vatican II, either in general or in its specific condemnation of anti-Semitism and its outreach to the Jewish people.
Yet the pope placed most of the blame for the Catholic outcry he provoked on critics he believes are too devoted to the changes decreed by Vatican II. Thus he says: "I was saddened by the fact that even Catholics who, after all, might have had a better knowledge of the situation, thought they had to attack me with open hostility." Even while making it clear to the Society of St. Pius X that "the Church’s teaching authority cannot be frozen in the year 1962," Benedict feels compelled to add: "But some of those who put themselves forward as great defenders of the Council also need to be reminded that Vatican II embraces the entire doctrinal history of the Church. Anyone who wishes to be obedient to the Council has to accept the faith professed over the centuries, and cannot sever the roots from which the tree draws its life."
The pope goes on to accuse such defenders of Vatican II of misusing their freedom, "biting and devouring" those they criticize like the people Paul chastized in Galatians 5:13-15, and of attacking him merely because he tried to reach out to estranged fellow Catholics: "At times one gets the impression that our society needs to have at least one group to which no tolerance may be shown; which one can easily attack and hate. And should someone dare to approach them – in this case the Pope – he too loses any right to tolerance; he too can be treated hatefully, without misgiving or restraint."
I join those commentators who have already found this over-wrought. But I am also afraid it indicates that the pope did not entirely 'get' what his critics were saying. By over-emphasizing how much Vatican II shares with the doctrinal history of the church, and by under-emphasizing the many ways in which the Council was a true reform of the past, the pope continues to exhibit the kind of tepid support for the Council for which he was criticized in the current controversy and in previous ones. Until he gives Vatican II its due, in word and in deed, he should not expect the proponents of Vatican II to agree with him or trust him or be silent when he tries to diminish the Council's importance.
Spiegel Online International offered this summary of the pope's letter: "Pope Benedict XVI has made a rare admission of a 'mishap' in the Vatican's handling of Holocaust denier Bishop Richard Williamson. A cardinal partly to blame for the debacle has been stripped of his power, and the pope says the Vatican ought to make better use of the Internet--to inform itself about crises more quickly."
The article continued: "The Ecclesia Dei Pontifical Commission, which was responsible for the Richard Williamson case, is being dissolved and will be merged with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith... As a result, Cardinal DarÃo Castrillón Hoyos, who triggered the Williamson debacle in mid-January, has been deprived of his power and, at almost 80, will slip into a well-earned retirement. 'Now that was quite a crash,' a prelate who witnessed the events said on Wednesday afternoon "
The article also noted that, in a substantive effort to improve communications within the Vatican bureaucracy, the pope appeared to be specifically directing the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith to use a regular Wednesday meeting of Vatican department heads to ensure that all of them were on the same page on issues of major significance.
The Vatican issued official translations of the pope's letter this morning. The English translation confirms the points Spiegel emphasized. The pope acknowledges that the nearly simultaneous lifting of the excommunications and Bishop Williamson's reiteration of his Holocaust denial "caused, both within and beyond the Catholic Church, a discussion more heated than any we have seen for a long time." He said it was "An unforeseen mishap for me...that the Williamson case came on top of the remission of the excommunication."
The pope said he did not intend lifting the excommunications of four traditionalist bishops to be seen as turning back the clock on Vatican II, either in general or in its specific condemnation of anti-Semitism and its outreach to the Jewish people.
Yet the pope placed most of the blame for the Catholic outcry he provoked on critics he believes are too devoted to the changes decreed by Vatican II. Thus he says: "I was saddened by the fact that even Catholics who, after all, might have had a better knowledge of the situation, thought they had to attack me with open hostility." Even while making it clear to the Society of St. Pius X that "the Church’s teaching authority cannot be frozen in the year 1962," Benedict feels compelled to add: "But some of those who put themselves forward as great defenders of the Council also need to be reminded that Vatican II embraces the entire doctrinal history of the Church. Anyone who wishes to be obedient to the Council has to accept the faith professed over the centuries, and cannot sever the roots from which the tree draws its life."
The pope goes on to accuse such defenders of Vatican II of misusing their freedom, "biting and devouring" those they criticize like the people Paul chastized in Galatians 5:13-15, and of attacking him merely because he tried to reach out to estranged fellow Catholics: "At times one gets the impression that our society needs to have at least one group to which no tolerance may be shown; which one can easily attack and hate. And should someone dare to approach them – in this case the Pope – he too loses any right to tolerance; he too can be treated hatefully, without misgiving or restraint."
I join those commentators who have already found this over-wrought. But I am also afraid it indicates that the pope did not entirely 'get' what his critics were saying. By over-emphasizing how much Vatican II shares with the doctrinal history of the church, and by under-emphasizing the many ways in which the Council was a true reform of the past, the pope continues to exhibit the kind of tepid support for the Council for which he was criticized in the current controversy and in previous ones. Until he gives Vatican II its due, in word and in deed, he should not expect the proponents of Vatican II to agree with him or trust him or be silent when he tries to diminish the Council's importance.
Friday, March 06, 2009
Former Catholic Ultraconservatives Again Refuse to Accept Second Vatican Council
It appears that Pope Benedict XVI's effort to reconcile the Society of St. Pius X (devotees of the late schismatic Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre) with the Catholic Church has hit the same obstacle that blocked outreach attempts by previous pontiffs: the Vatican insists that they must accept the teachings of the Second Vatican Council in full, but the former Catholic ultraconservatives still decline to do so.
So says a report from Catholic News Service, linked by the National Catholic Reporter. It reports that self-styled bishop Bernard Fellay, Lefebvre's successor as head of SSPX and one of the five Lefebvre-consecrated bishops whose excommunication Benedict lifted, remains "not ready to accept Vatican II."
Evidently SSPX and the five bishops have misread Benedict: they see the pope's outreach as an opportunity to negotiate with Rome about which Vatican II teachings the pope should overrule.
Fortunately, it appears that Benedict may finally gotten the point that overruling anything solemnly taught by the bishops and pope at Vatican II is not within the scope of his authority. Let us pray that he will be steadfast in the position that Vatican II is non-negotiable.
So says a report from Catholic News Service, linked by the National Catholic Reporter. It reports that self-styled bishop Bernard Fellay, Lefebvre's successor as head of SSPX and one of the five Lefebvre-consecrated bishops whose excommunication Benedict lifted, remains "not ready to accept Vatican II."
Evidently SSPX and the five bishops have misread Benedict: they see the pope's outreach as an opportunity to negotiate with Rome about which Vatican II teachings the pope should overrule.
Fortunately, it appears that Benedict may finally gotten the point that overruling anything solemnly taught by the bishops and pope at Vatican II is not within the scope of his authority. Let us pray that he will be steadfast in the position that Vatican II is non-negotiable.
Monday, March 02, 2009
Proposition 8's Gay Marriage Ban Back Before the California Supreme Court on Thursday
MSNBC and the Associated Press report that on Thursday opponents of California's Proposition 8--which took away the right of gay couples to marry, even though the California Supreme Court said the state constitution protected it--will return to the court to argue that Proposition 8 itself is unconstitutional.
Experts noted that it would be highly unusual for a state supreme court to overrule the will of the people in passing a state initiative. Opponents are arguing that Proposition 8 was not just an amendment to the state constitution but a substantial revision, which under state law should not have been submitted to the voters until it was first approved by the state legislature. They also note there is no precedent in California allowing voters to take rights away from minorities--and that other minorities should feel as threatened by the move as gay people do. In the words of the article:
"Legal experts say Proposition 8, which won 52 percent of the vote, would almost certainly stand if not for one notable fact: the marriage amendment represents the first time in California history that the constitution was changed at the ballot box to deprive a protected minority group of a right expressly carved out by the court.
"'It would be unprecedented for the court to overturn Proposition 8 only because Proposition 8 is unprecedented,' said Dale Carpenter, a University of Minnesota constitutional law professor."
The article adds that California Attorney General (and former governor) Jerry Brown has refused to defend the initiative and is asking the justices to invalidate it.
Interestingly, there is precedent for a court to overturn an initiative passed by a majority of California voters. In 1964 California voters favored Proposition 14, crafted to overturn the Rumford Fair Housing Act, which prohibited discrimination in the sale or rental of housing "because of ethnicity, religion, sex, marital status, physical handicap, or familial status."
In 1967 the initiative itself was overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court, on grounds that it violated the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. The court made it clear that no constitution gives California voters an absolute right to enact anything they damn well please.
Experts noted that it would be highly unusual for a state supreme court to overrule the will of the people in passing a state initiative. Opponents are arguing that Proposition 8 was not just an amendment to the state constitution but a substantial revision, which under state law should not have been submitted to the voters until it was first approved by the state legislature. They also note there is no precedent in California allowing voters to take rights away from minorities--and that other minorities should feel as threatened by the move as gay people do. In the words of the article:
"Legal experts say Proposition 8, which won 52 percent of the vote, would almost certainly stand if not for one notable fact: the marriage amendment represents the first time in California history that the constitution was changed at the ballot box to deprive a protected minority group of a right expressly carved out by the court.
"'It would be unprecedented for the court to overturn Proposition 8 only because Proposition 8 is unprecedented,' said Dale Carpenter, a University of Minnesota constitutional law professor."
The article adds that California Attorney General (and former governor) Jerry Brown has refused to defend the initiative and is asking the justices to invalidate it.
Interestingly, there is precedent for a court to overturn an initiative passed by a majority of California voters. In 1964 California voters favored Proposition 14, crafted to overturn the Rumford Fair Housing Act, which prohibited discrimination in the sale or rental of housing "because of ethnicity, religion, sex, marital status, physical handicap, or familial status."
In 1967 the initiative itself was overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court, on grounds that it violated the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. The court made it clear that no constitution gives California voters an absolute right to enact anything they damn well please.
Holocaust-Denying 'Bishop' Gets More Just Deserts; Vatican Keeps Distancing Itself
The National Catholic Reporter and Google are linking to an Associated Press article which says that traditionalist 'bishop' Richard Williamson continues to suffer church and state consequences for denying the magnitude of the Holocaust--thereby gracing the Vatican with further opportunities to distance itself from him and uphold the Second Vatican Council's teachings on the Jewish people's unique and unsurpassable role in salvation history.
One of last week's civil consequences for Williamson was that the government of Argentina ordered Williamson to leave because of his remarks. On arriving in his native Britain, Williamson told the media he would never have made them had he known "the full harm and hurt to which they would give rise."
According to AP the Vatican said Friday that that wasn't good enough and that Williamson has to repudiate his views if he wants to serve as member of the Catholic clergy. The Vatican had already made this a non-negotiable condition for Williamson to return to official ministry, but Friday's statement underscored that Rome is in earnest about it and will not relent until Williamson does.
Meanwhile, another civil consequence looms. State prosecutors in Regensburg, Germany, (where Benedict XVI was a professor from 1969 to 1977) already had opened a preliminary investigation into whether Williamson broke German laws against Holocaust denial. AP said that on Friday the German justice minister said she is considering issuing a Europe-wide arrest warrant for Williamson on hate-crime charges, because Williamson made his remarks in Germany in an interview with Swedish television.
If continued exclusion from Catholic ministry is not enough to dissuade Williamson, perhaps a jail cell will be.
One of last week's civil consequences for Williamson was that the government of Argentina ordered Williamson to leave because of his remarks. On arriving in his native Britain, Williamson told the media he would never have made them had he known "the full harm and hurt to which they would give rise."
According to AP the Vatican said Friday that that wasn't good enough and that Williamson has to repudiate his views if he wants to serve as member of the Catholic clergy. The Vatican had already made this a non-negotiable condition for Williamson to return to official ministry, but Friday's statement underscored that Rome is in earnest about it and will not relent until Williamson does.
Meanwhile, another civil consequence looms. State prosecutors in Regensburg, Germany, (where Benedict XVI was a professor from 1969 to 1977) already had opened a preliminary investigation into whether Williamson broke German laws against Holocaust denial. AP said that on Friday the German justice minister said she is considering issuing a Europe-wide arrest warrant for Williamson on hate-crime charges, because Williamson made his remarks in Germany in an interview with Swedish television.
If continued exclusion from Catholic ministry is not enough to dissuade Williamson, perhaps a jail cell will be.
Wednesday, February 18, 2009
Austrian Bishops Say Vatican Communication Skills Impeding Pope, Need Improvement
Reuters reports that on Monday Austria's bishops chided Pope Benedict XVI for inadequate communication skills and pledged that unlike the pope's recent attempt to appoint an ultraconservative as auxiliary bishop of Linz they would ensure their involvement in future nominations of Austrian bishops. While the rebuke was not as harsh as it might have been, it at least allowed a theologian at the University of Vienna to cheer that the bishops had overcome an attempt by Austrian church conservatives to sideline them. The Reuters report follows.
Austria's diocesan bishops on Monday urged the Vatican to improve its inadequate communication skills, after holding an emergency meeting to discuss a crisis of confidence in the Catholic church.
Austrian Catholicism is in turmoil because Pope Benedict, one week after readmitting Holocaust denier Bishop Richard Williamson, named an auxiliary bishop in Linz who said Hurricane Katrina in 2005 was God punishing New Orleans for its sins.
"We hope inadequate channels of communication in the Vatican can be improved so the Pope's service to humanity is not impaired," Austria's bishops said in a statement after their day-long meeting.
The Williamson case and the appointment of Gerhard Maria Wagner in Linz sparked doubts about the Pope's leadership and concern the church was taking an increasingly conservative turn.
Both decisions were apparently taken without consultation with local churches.
Last week, 31 of the 39 deans (senior priests) in the Linz diocese passed a declaration of no confidence in Wagner, a rare event in the tightly governed Catholic Church. Wagner withdrew on Sunday, and the Vatican accepted his decision, the Catholic news agency Kathpress reported.
Austria's bishops said it was essential for the Pope to have reliable and thorough briefings before appointing bishops.
Faced with rising numbers of Catholics quitting the church and protests from clergy, Vienna Cardinal Christoph Schoenborn called all diocesan bishops to Monday's meeting to "give our best to overcome the crisis."
The bishops expressed solidarity with the Pope but linked the communication problems and lack of adherence to official nomination procedures to the disputed promotion of Wagner.
"We bishops will do everything within our power to insure the upcoming bishop nominations are conducted according with the official procedure, in close cooperation with the relevant Vatican officials," they said.
Paul Zulehner, a theologian at the University of Vienna, called the Wagner nomination a putsch by church conservatives in Austria and an attempt to sideline the official church leaders.
"The seizure of power by the right-wingers has now failed, apparently through the clear intervention of several Austrian bishops," he said.
"I think people will now say: 'it is really good that Cardinal Schoenborn has taken over the leadership of the Church again'," Zulehner added.
(Reporting by Sarah Marsh; Editing by Jon Boyle)
Austria's diocesan bishops on Monday urged the Vatican to improve its inadequate communication skills, after holding an emergency meeting to discuss a crisis of confidence in the Catholic church.
Austrian Catholicism is in turmoil because Pope Benedict, one week after readmitting Holocaust denier Bishop Richard Williamson, named an auxiliary bishop in Linz who said Hurricane Katrina in 2005 was God punishing New Orleans for its sins.
"We hope inadequate channels of communication in the Vatican can be improved so the Pope's service to humanity is not impaired," Austria's bishops said in a statement after their day-long meeting.
The Williamson case and the appointment of Gerhard Maria Wagner in Linz sparked doubts about the Pope's leadership and concern the church was taking an increasingly conservative turn.
Both decisions were apparently taken without consultation with local churches.
Last week, 31 of the 39 deans (senior priests) in the Linz diocese passed a declaration of no confidence in Wagner, a rare event in the tightly governed Catholic Church. Wagner withdrew on Sunday, and the Vatican accepted his decision, the Catholic news agency Kathpress reported.
Austria's bishops said it was essential for the Pope to have reliable and thorough briefings before appointing bishops.
Faced with rising numbers of Catholics quitting the church and protests from clergy, Vienna Cardinal Christoph Schoenborn called all diocesan bishops to Monday's meeting to "give our best to overcome the crisis."
The bishops expressed solidarity with the Pope but linked the communication problems and lack of adherence to official nomination procedures to the disputed promotion of Wagner.
"We bishops will do everything within our power to insure the upcoming bishop nominations are conducted according with the official procedure, in close cooperation with the relevant Vatican officials," they said.
Paul Zulehner, a theologian at the University of Vienna, called the Wagner nomination a putsch by church conservatives in Austria and an attempt to sideline the official church leaders.
"The seizure of power by the right-wingers has now failed, apparently through the clear intervention of several Austrian bishops," he said.
"I think people will now say: 'it is really good that Cardinal Schoenborn has taken over the leadership of the Church again'," Zulehner added.
(Reporting by Sarah Marsh; Editing by Jon Boyle)
Monday, February 16, 2009
Austrian Bishops Hold Emergency Meeting on Church Crisis; Bishop Nominee Withdraws
The week begins with media outlets reporting new developments in Austria in the aftermath of the recent crisis of authority in the Catholic Church. Pope Benedict XVI provoked a worldwide crisis by welcoming back a schismatic ultraconservative bishop who denies the legitimacy of the Second Vatican Council and the actuality of the Holocaust--and a crisis in Austria in particular by promoting as an auxiliary bishop of Linz, Austria's third largest city and a major academic center, pastor Gerhard Maria Wagner, who has claimed that Hurricane Katrina was God's punishment for New Orleans' sins, the Harry Potter books are satanic, and homosexuality could be cured.
Reuters reports that Vienna Cardinal Christoph Schoenborn called all of the Austrian bishops to the one-day meeting today in an attempt to calm the uproar. A few paragraphs from the article:
The two appointments, both apparently without consultation with local churches, sparked doubt about Benedict's leadership and concern the Church was turning increasingly conservative.
Schoenborn said the uproar had caused "irritation and resignation" and the Church needed "damage control" for the sake of its future, according to the Catholic news agency Kathpress.
Four times as many Catholics have officially quit the Church in Linz so far this year as in early 2008, the Austrian Press Agency APA reported, and departures have also been running higher than usual in Vienna, Salzburg, Tyrol and Lower Austria.
On Tuesday, 31 of the 39 deans (senior priests) of the Linz diocese passed a declaration of no confidence in Wagner, who has condemned the Harry Potter books as satanic, said homosexuality was curable and ruled out lay participation in Church affairs.
Schoenborn's spokesman Erich Leitenberger said the timing of Wagner's appointment fueled an uproar unleashed by the lifting of excommunications against Williamson and three other bishops of the ultra-traditionalist Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX).
"The proximity of those two events has for some people created the impression there was a masterplan, that the Church wanted to roll back the Second Vatican Council," he said, referring to major Church reforms from the 1960s.
Meanwhile, Google is carrying an Associated Press report from yesterday that the Bishop of Linz issued a statement that Wagner has asked Benedict to reverse his appointment as auxiliary. The bishop declined to comment on Wagner's request, but said that more information would result from today's meeting of the bishops.
Reuters reports that Vienna Cardinal Christoph Schoenborn called all of the Austrian bishops to the one-day meeting today in an attempt to calm the uproar. A few paragraphs from the article:
The two appointments, both apparently without consultation with local churches, sparked doubt about Benedict's leadership and concern the Church was turning increasingly conservative.
Schoenborn said the uproar had caused "irritation and resignation" and the Church needed "damage control" for the sake of its future, according to the Catholic news agency Kathpress.
Four times as many Catholics have officially quit the Church in Linz so far this year as in early 2008, the Austrian Press Agency APA reported, and departures have also been running higher than usual in Vienna, Salzburg, Tyrol and Lower Austria.
On Tuesday, 31 of the 39 deans (senior priests) of the Linz diocese passed a declaration of no confidence in Wagner, who has condemned the Harry Potter books as satanic, said homosexuality was curable and ruled out lay participation in Church affairs.
Schoenborn's spokesman Erich Leitenberger said the timing of Wagner's appointment fueled an uproar unleashed by the lifting of excommunications against Williamson and three other bishops of the ultra-traditionalist Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX).
"The proximity of those two events has for some people created the impression there was a masterplan, that the Church wanted to roll back the Second Vatican Council," he said, referring to major Church reforms from the 1960s.
Meanwhile, Google is carrying an Associated Press report from yesterday that the Bishop of Linz issued a statement that Wagner has asked Benedict to reverse his appointment as auxiliary. The bishop declined to comment on Wagner's request, but said that more information would result from today's meeting of the bishops.
Thursday, February 12, 2009
Happy Birthday, Charles Darwin -- And Thanks for "Questioning the Unquestionable."
Today is the 200th anniversary of Charles Darwin's birth, and CNN has a good article explaining why his description of evolution is such a significant turning point in human self-understanding and particularly in the fields of science, history, politics, philosophy and theology.
The writer reminds us of something that Darwin fans and foes tend to forget: that among Darwin's academic achievements was a degree in theology from Cambridge. Perhaps that helped Darwin to appreciate the significance of his discoveries and motivated him to promote that significance publicly.
The article notes that in the United States today only 14% of people polled accept evolution exactly as Darwin taught it. The same poll found that 44% cling to a literal reading of Genesis and another 36% believe that evolution happened over a much longer time frame, but led and guided by God. That makes God's role, if any, an appropriate topic in philosophy and theology classrooms and journals, but not for the biological sciences.
The article also notes that Abraham Lincoln shared the exact same birth date--and notes the curious parallels that both felt a calling to put an end to slavery and that Lincoln issued his Emancipation Proclamation just a few years after Darwin published "On the Origin of Species" in 1859. Most of CNN's article follows:
Before there was an extensive fossil record, DNA sequencing or even a basic understanding of genetics, there was Charles Darwin.
Today, the world commemorates the 200th birthday of a man who single-handedly revolutionized biology with an explosive theory that challenged the core of our existence.
"Darwin wrote about who we are," said historian and author James Moore, who has cowritten a new book on the famous evolutionist. "He gave us a re-interpretation of the history of humans on earth, and what we can become."
Darwin's theory of evolution proposes that humans evolved over millions of years from animal species, specifically apes. Such thinking, which challenged the biblical account that a deity created the Earth in six days, was considered radical, even blasphemous, when Darwin published it in 1859.
A century and a half later, the legacy of history's most noted naturalist continues to make headlines.
After a contentious debate, the Texas Board of Education is set to vote in March on how evolution should be taught in the state's public schools. Last week, actor-comedian Ben Stein backed out of giving a commencement speech at the University of Vermont because of student complaints about his views challenging the theory of evolution.
The most recent Gallup poll on the issue, conducted in May, found that only 14 percent of Americans believe that humans developed over millions of years from less advanced forms of life. Forty-four percent believe that God created human beings almost overnight within the past 10,000 years, and another 36 percent believe that God guided humans' evolution from animals over a much longer period of time.
"The problem is, there are a number of fundamental people on both the left and the right extremes," said Michael Zimmerman, founder of the Clergy Letter Project, which seeks to find common ground between scientists and the clergy.
"Most people think you can't believe in evolution and have faith," added Zimmerman, a dean at Butler University in Indianapolis, Indiana. "Faith does not mean that you have to give up common sense. Faith is deeper than that."
Darwin devoted much of his adult life to questioning the unquestionable. Born February 12, 1809, in Shrewsbury, England, he earned a degree in theology from Cambridge University and was known for his obsession with collecting things, especially beetles.
His outlook on life changed after he embarked in 1831 on a five-year voyage around the world on the HMS Beagle, a British naval ship. His observations during the journey inspired Darwin to develop his theory of natural selection, the process by which organisms that are best adapted to their environment produce more offspring while those less suited eventually die out.
After spending 20 years meticulously crafting and weighing the implications of his theory, Darwin finally went public with his life's work. "On the Origin of Species," his landmark book about evolution and natural selection, was published in 1859.
Darwin was an unassuming scholar who wanted to make a humble contribution to the world of science, but his ideas on evolution were heresy to much of 18th-century England. The implication that our past, present and futures are all connected in an integrated web shook the biological, religious and political foundations of life as it was believed to be.
"The world was not the same after its publication," said Sean B. Carroll, a professor of molecular biology and genetics at the University of Wisconsin and author of a new book, "Remarkable Creatures: Epic Adventures in the Search for the Origin of Species."
Central to Darwin's thesis was his scientific explanation of life's diversity: that all life evolved from a common lineage through the process of natural selection. This egalitarian view was not popular with those who professed their anthropological superiority over people of other races.
"Darwin's theory challenged the notions of human exceptionalism and brought to light this idea that humans are a result of natural processes, meaning we were not as 'special' as [we] once thought," said Eugenie Scott, a physical anthropologist and the executive director of the National Center for Science Education.
Darwin shares a birth date with Abraham Lincoln, who sought to end slavery in the United States soon after "On the Origin of Species" was published. A major driving force behind Darwin's research was his own disdain for slavery, prejudice and human suffering.
"He had a deep regard for humanity and living entities," said Moore, who co-authored a new book, "Darwin's Sacred Cause," about the influence of slavery on Darwin's thinking. "There was no high or low, better or worse. Things were just different."
But most of Darwin's theories are now accepted as a foundation of biological science.
"The evidence for evolution is overwhelming. We can see it all around us," said Carroll, the University of Wisconsin professor. "He teaches us that life is continually adapting to keep up with a changing Earth."
This continual fight for survival may resonate more loudly today than ever. In the 21st century, climate change is forcing species to evolve more quickly to survive on a warming planet, scientists say.
If drought conditions intensify and deforestation continues, many scientists expect to see great changes in the biological compositions of ecosystems over the coming decades.
In other words, Darwin's theory of natural selection is still very much in evidence.
"Changing ecological systems are causing intense environmental pressures on organisms," said Scott, of the National Center for Science Education. "We are seeing rapid species growth and waves of extinction all at the same time."
The writer reminds us of something that Darwin fans and foes tend to forget: that among Darwin's academic achievements was a degree in theology from Cambridge. Perhaps that helped Darwin to appreciate the significance of his discoveries and motivated him to promote that significance publicly.
The article notes that in the United States today only 14% of people polled accept evolution exactly as Darwin taught it. The same poll found that 44% cling to a literal reading of Genesis and another 36% believe that evolution happened over a much longer time frame, but led and guided by God. That makes God's role, if any, an appropriate topic in philosophy and theology classrooms and journals, but not for the biological sciences.
The article also notes that Abraham Lincoln shared the exact same birth date--and notes the curious parallels that both felt a calling to put an end to slavery and that Lincoln issued his Emancipation Proclamation just a few years after Darwin published "On the Origin of Species" in 1859. Most of CNN's article follows:
Before there was an extensive fossil record, DNA sequencing or even a basic understanding of genetics, there was Charles Darwin.
Today, the world commemorates the 200th birthday of a man who single-handedly revolutionized biology with an explosive theory that challenged the core of our existence.
"Darwin wrote about who we are," said historian and author James Moore, who has cowritten a new book on the famous evolutionist. "He gave us a re-interpretation of the history of humans on earth, and what we can become."
Darwin's theory of evolution proposes that humans evolved over millions of years from animal species, specifically apes. Such thinking, which challenged the biblical account that a deity created the Earth in six days, was considered radical, even blasphemous, when Darwin published it in 1859.
A century and a half later, the legacy of history's most noted naturalist continues to make headlines.
After a contentious debate, the Texas Board of Education is set to vote in March on how evolution should be taught in the state's public schools. Last week, actor-comedian Ben Stein backed out of giving a commencement speech at the University of Vermont because of student complaints about his views challenging the theory of evolution.
The most recent Gallup poll on the issue, conducted in May, found that only 14 percent of Americans believe that humans developed over millions of years from less advanced forms of life. Forty-four percent believe that God created human beings almost overnight within the past 10,000 years, and another 36 percent believe that God guided humans' evolution from animals over a much longer period of time.
"The problem is, there are a number of fundamental people on both the left and the right extremes," said Michael Zimmerman, founder of the Clergy Letter Project, which seeks to find common ground between scientists and the clergy.
"Most people think you can't believe in evolution and have faith," added Zimmerman, a dean at Butler University in Indianapolis, Indiana. "Faith does not mean that you have to give up common sense. Faith is deeper than that."
Darwin devoted much of his adult life to questioning the unquestionable. Born February 12, 1809, in Shrewsbury, England, he earned a degree in theology from Cambridge University and was known for his obsession with collecting things, especially beetles.
His outlook on life changed after he embarked in 1831 on a five-year voyage around the world on the HMS Beagle, a British naval ship. His observations during the journey inspired Darwin to develop his theory of natural selection, the process by which organisms that are best adapted to their environment produce more offspring while those less suited eventually die out.
After spending 20 years meticulously crafting and weighing the implications of his theory, Darwin finally went public with his life's work. "On the Origin of Species," his landmark book about evolution and natural selection, was published in 1859.
Darwin was an unassuming scholar who wanted to make a humble contribution to the world of science, but his ideas on evolution were heresy to much of 18th-century England. The implication that our past, present and futures are all connected in an integrated web shook the biological, religious and political foundations of life as it was believed to be.
"The world was not the same after its publication," said Sean B. Carroll, a professor of molecular biology and genetics at the University of Wisconsin and author of a new book, "Remarkable Creatures: Epic Adventures in the Search for the Origin of Species."
Central to Darwin's thesis was his scientific explanation of life's diversity: that all life evolved from a common lineage through the process of natural selection. This egalitarian view was not popular with those who professed their anthropological superiority over people of other races.
"Darwin's theory challenged the notions of human exceptionalism and brought to light this idea that humans are a result of natural processes, meaning we were not as 'special' as [we] once thought," said Eugenie Scott, a physical anthropologist and the executive director of the National Center for Science Education.
Darwin shares a birth date with Abraham Lincoln, who sought to end slavery in the United States soon after "On the Origin of Species" was published. A major driving force behind Darwin's research was his own disdain for slavery, prejudice and human suffering.
"He had a deep regard for humanity and living entities," said Moore, who co-authored a new book, "Darwin's Sacred Cause," about the influence of slavery on Darwin's thinking. "There was no high or low, better or worse. Things were just different."
But most of Darwin's theories are now accepted as a foundation of biological science.
"The evidence for evolution is overwhelming. We can see it all around us," said Carroll, the University of Wisconsin professor. "He teaches us that life is continually adapting to keep up with a changing Earth."
This continual fight for survival may resonate more loudly today than ever. In the 21st century, climate change is forcing species to evolve more quickly to survive on a warming planet, scientists say.
If drought conditions intensify and deforestation continues, many scientists expect to see great changes in the biological compositions of ecosystems over the coming decades.
In other words, Darwin's theory of natural selection is still very much in evidence.
"Changing ecological systems are causing intense environmental pressures on organisms," said Scott, of the National Center for Science Education. "We are seeing rapid species growth and waves of extinction all at the same time."
Tuesday, February 10, 2009
European Theologians and Faithful Petition Rome to Abide by Teachings of Vatican II
Queering the Church, a Catholic blog written near London, reports that theologians and Christians in Germany, Austria and Switzerland plan to send a petition to Rome, calling on the pope to refrain from undermining several of the decrees of Vatican II, fully implement all of the council's decrees, and pursue dialogue with all movements in the church, not just those on the far right. The petition is being circulated in England by We Are Church UK. The petition follows, along with a link that encourages concerned believers to sign it.
THE PETITION
The papal cancellation of the excommunication of bishops from The Society of St. Pius X signifies the reception into full communion with the See of Rome those who have consistently opposed the reforms of the Second Vatican Council.
Regarding the anti-Semitic remarks and the denial of the German national-socialist persecution of the Jews by Bishop Richard Williamson and his followers, we share the indignation of our Jewish sisters and brothers. Moreover, we state that the SSPX’s attitude towards Judaism does not correspond to the Council’s understanding of and commitment to Jewish-Christian dialogue.
We support the recent statements of Bishops’ Conferences, and others, all over the world, on this issue. We also welcome the recent statements made on these matters by Pope Benedict XVI and the Vatican’s Secretariat of State.
We believe that the close correlation between the excommunication’s cancellation and the 50th anniversary of the calling of a General Council of the Church by Blessed Pope John XXIII gives a clear indication of the direction which the present Papacy wishes to take. We sense a desire to return to a pre-Vatican II Church with its fear of openness to the breath of the Holy Spirit, a positive appreciation of ’the signs of the times’, and the values of democratic institutions.
We are very concerned that this act of rehabilitation heralds a turn-around on important documents of Vatican II, for example, the decree on ecumenism, Unitatis Redintegratio, the declaration on non-Christian religions, Nostra Aetate, the declaration on religious liberty, Dignitatis Humanae, and the Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World, Gaudium et Spes. Such an act will have a disastrous effect on the credibility of the Roman-Catholic Church. For Catholics who love their Church, the price is too high!
The Pope hopes this act will help unify the Church. However we think it is particularly outrageous that the Vatican’s renewed overtures to a schismatic traditionalist movement have been undertaken without the imposition of any conditions whatsoever. In June 2008, on the occasion of the 20th anniversary of Lefebvre’s excommunication, the SSPX rejected the invitation of the Holy See towards theological reconciliation. Likewise, the fraternity rejected the invitation to sign a five-topic declaration containing conditions for its re-integration in the Roman Church.
A return to full communion with the Catholic Church can only be made possible if the documents and teachings of the Second Vatican Council are fully accepted without any reservations, as requested by the motu proprio, Summorum Pontificum, on the topic of the Tridentine rite. It is also imperative that the papal ministries of Blessed Pope John XXIII, Pope Paul VI, Pope John Paul I, Pope John Paul II, and Pope Benedict XVI are recognised and accepted.
The Church of Rome, perceived as the Barque of St Peter, lists heavily as long as the Vatican:
+ only rehabilitates the ‘lost sheep’ at the traditionalist edge of the Church, and makes no similar offer to other excommunicated or marginalised Catholics
+ persists in preventing progressive theologians from teaching
+ refuses dialogue with all movements in the Church
We Are Church UK 5 February 2009
(Based upon an original text by Prof. Dr. Norbert Scholl, Angelhofweg 24b, D-69259 Wilhelmsfeld published in Essen on 28 January 2009)
Please add your signature
THE PETITION
The papal cancellation of the excommunication of bishops from The Society of St. Pius X signifies the reception into full communion with the See of Rome those who have consistently opposed the reforms of the Second Vatican Council.
Regarding the anti-Semitic remarks and the denial of the German national-socialist persecution of the Jews by Bishop Richard Williamson and his followers, we share the indignation of our Jewish sisters and brothers. Moreover, we state that the SSPX’s attitude towards Judaism does not correspond to the Council’s understanding of and commitment to Jewish-Christian dialogue.
We support the recent statements of Bishops’ Conferences, and others, all over the world, on this issue. We also welcome the recent statements made on these matters by Pope Benedict XVI and the Vatican’s Secretariat of State.
We believe that the close correlation between the excommunication’s cancellation and the 50th anniversary of the calling of a General Council of the Church by Blessed Pope John XXIII gives a clear indication of the direction which the present Papacy wishes to take. We sense a desire to return to a pre-Vatican II Church with its fear of openness to the breath of the Holy Spirit, a positive appreciation of ’the signs of the times’, and the values of democratic institutions.
We are very concerned that this act of rehabilitation heralds a turn-around on important documents of Vatican II, for example, the decree on ecumenism, Unitatis Redintegratio, the declaration on non-Christian religions, Nostra Aetate, the declaration on religious liberty, Dignitatis Humanae, and the Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World, Gaudium et Spes. Such an act will have a disastrous effect on the credibility of the Roman-Catholic Church. For Catholics who love their Church, the price is too high!
The Pope hopes this act will help unify the Church. However we think it is particularly outrageous that the Vatican’s renewed overtures to a schismatic traditionalist movement have been undertaken without the imposition of any conditions whatsoever. In June 2008, on the occasion of the 20th anniversary of Lefebvre’s excommunication, the SSPX rejected the invitation of the Holy See towards theological reconciliation. Likewise, the fraternity rejected the invitation to sign a five-topic declaration containing conditions for its re-integration in the Roman Church.
A return to full communion with the Catholic Church can only be made possible if the documents and teachings of the Second Vatican Council are fully accepted without any reservations, as requested by the motu proprio, Summorum Pontificum, on the topic of the Tridentine rite. It is also imperative that the papal ministries of Blessed Pope John XXIII, Pope Paul VI, Pope John Paul I, Pope John Paul II, and Pope Benedict XVI are recognised and accepted.
The Church of Rome, perceived as the Barque of St Peter, lists heavily as long as the Vatican:
+ only rehabilitates the ‘lost sheep’ at the traditionalist edge of the Church, and makes no similar offer to other excommunicated or marginalised Catholics
+ persists in preventing progressive theologians from teaching
+ refuses dialogue with all movements in the Church
We Are Church UK 5 February 2009
(Based upon an original text by Prof. Dr. Norbert Scholl, Angelhofweg 24b, D-69259 Wilhelmsfeld published in Essen on 28 January 2009)
Please add your signature
Post-Postings: Progress on Guns on Campus; Regress on Saving Live Oak Trees
Every so often, a news or opinion item notes novel developments on issues I've addressed in previous blog postings. As luck would have it, two appeared in the opinion section of today's Houston Chronicle.
One is an editorial calling recently proposed laws to allow concealed guns on Texas college campuses "not such a bright idea."
Such proposals are not new, whether from a Texas perspective or even nationwide. But they reached a fever pitch in the wake of the on-campus shootings at Virginia Tech on April 18, 2007. Two days later I decried the complete insanity of the idea in a posting entitled Nothing a Few More Guns Wouldn't Fix! The concern was also in the background when I argued that the Supreme Court's subsequent gun ruling mistakenly found in the 2nd Amendment A New Right to Kill, but virtually ignored clear historical evidence on the real right to bear arms that the Founders codified--evidence which no Supreme Court justice disputed.
So it will come as no surprise that I find the Chronicle's arguments against arming college students to be persuasive. More importantly, so does everyone at Virginia Tech today, along with the student government of the University of Texas in Austin.
But until the editorial I was not aware of an even more positive development: "After the horrendous carnage on the campus of Virginia Tech in 2007... Seventeen states introduced measures to allow guns on campus. Voters turned them all down." It's especially gratifying that after extensive public discussion voters in one-third of the states have agreed that guns on campus is a lame-brained idea that, as the Chronicle says, would only "increase the vulnerability of students and others on campus."
The other topic was protecting live oak trees, one of the few natural assets in the Houston metropolitan area. This was the subject of my post on June 24, 2008, which highlighted efforts by "Trees for Houston" to prevent the city from destroying 126 live oak trees for the wholly unnecessary widening of a major thoroughfare. It was also addressed in a posting October 7, 2008, about the mayor's support for planting a million new trees in Houston over the next five years.
An opinion piece in today's Houston Chronicle reports some potential back-tracking on efforts to save the live oaks--this time by the City Council's Quality of Life Committee, no less--and urges the citizenry to oppose it.
What's new is proposed revisions to Houston's tree and shrub ordinance after so many trees broke power lines during Hurricane Ike. The column points out, however, that no one has documented power-line damage by any live oak tree--because all of the damage was done by higher-growing, less flexible trees, such as tall pines, water willows, red oaks and post oaks.
For this reason, the advisory committee that recommended the ordinance changes did not prohibit live oaks under power lines. But after receiving the advisory committee's report, the Quality of Life Committee inserted the words "small tree" in the power line section, expressly to include live oaks. The council committee did this without telling the advisory committee, and the advisory committee has cried foul.
The author of the opinion piece appears to know what he's talking about: Hugh Rice Kelly is a retired executive vice president and general counsel for Houston's Reliant Energy! He says the real reason the Quality of Life Committee now wants to authorize destruction of live oak trees under power lines is that CenterPoint Energy is "tired of spending money to trim trees." Its previous tactics have included "a new kind of Texas chain-saw massacre: Mangle people's live oaks badly enough and maybe they will just give up and plant little bushes that don't hide the power line."
Kelly says people plant the live oaks because the power lines are ugly and the trees do the best job of hiding them. He urges the public to pressure the Houston City Council to back-off more live-oak destruction. The trees are worth a lot more to the region than the electric providers' bottom lines.
One is an editorial calling recently proposed laws to allow concealed guns on Texas college campuses "not such a bright idea."
Such proposals are not new, whether from a Texas perspective or even nationwide. But they reached a fever pitch in the wake of the on-campus shootings at Virginia Tech on April 18, 2007. Two days later I decried the complete insanity of the idea in a posting entitled Nothing a Few More Guns Wouldn't Fix! The concern was also in the background when I argued that the Supreme Court's subsequent gun ruling mistakenly found in the 2nd Amendment A New Right to Kill, but virtually ignored clear historical evidence on the real right to bear arms that the Founders codified--evidence which no Supreme Court justice disputed.
So it will come as no surprise that I find the Chronicle's arguments against arming college students to be persuasive. More importantly, so does everyone at Virginia Tech today, along with the student government of the University of Texas in Austin.
But until the editorial I was not aware of an even more positive development: "After the horrendous carnage on the campus of Virginia Tech in 2007... Seventeen states introduced measures to allow guns on campus. Voters turned them all down." It's especially gratifying that after extensive public discussion voters in one-third of the states have agreed that guns on campus is a lame-brained idea that, as the Chronicle says, would only "increase the vulnerability of students and others on campus."
The other topic was protecting live oak trees, one of the few natural assets in the Houston metropolitan area. This was the subject of my post on June 24, 2008, which highlighted efforts by "Trees for Houston" to prevent the city from destroying 126 live oak trees for the wholly unnecessary widening of a major thoroughfare. It was also addressed in a posting October 7, 2008, about the mayor's support for planting a million new trees in Houston over the next five years.
An opinion piece in today's Houston Chronicle reports some potential back-tracking on efforts to save the live oaks--this time by the City Council's Quality of Life Committee, no less--and urges the citizenry to oppose it.
What's new is proposed revisions to Houston's tree and shrub ordinance after so many trees broke power lines during Hurricane Ike. The column points out, however, that no one has documented power-line damage by any live oak tree--because all of the damage was done by higher-growing, less flexible trees, such as tall pines, water willows, red oaks and post oaks.
For this reason, the advisory committee that recommended the ordinance changes did not prohibit live oaks under power lines. But after receiving the advisory committee's report, the Quality of Life Committee inserted the words "small tree" in the power line section, expressly to include live oaks. The council committee did this without telling the advisory committee, and the advisory committee has cried foul.
The author of the opinion piece appears to know what he's talking about: Hugh Rice Kelly is a retired executive vice president and general counsel for Houston's Reliant Energy! He says the real reason the Quality of Life Committee now wants to authorize destruction of live oak trees under power lines is that CenterPoint Energy is "tired of spending money to trim trees." Its previous tactics have included "a new kind of Texas chain-saw massacre: Mangle people's live oaks badly enough and maybe they will just give up and plant little bushes that don't hide the power line."
Kelly says people plant the live oaks because the power lines are ugly and the trees do the best job of hiding them. He urges the public to pressure the Houston City Council to back-off more live-oak destruction. The trees are worth a lot more to the region than the electric providers' bottom lines.
Thursday, February 05, 2009
Rome Must Address New Questions Before It Can Make Its Abortion Teaching U.S. Law
Recent articles and letters in the National Catholic Reporter (NCR) raised significant new questions about the Vatican's on-going efforts to enact laws that would ban all abortions in the United States.
Several challenge the official church position that conception occurs and human life begins the instant a sperm fertilizes an ovum. Another charges that the U.S. bishops departed from their own long tradition of social justice leadership by saying so often that abortion is the most serious social evil in U.S. society.
In the December 26th NCR, William B. Neaves, president and CEO of the Stowers Institute for Medical Research in Kansas City, Mo., asked simply, When does a person become a person?
His starting point is that Dignitas Personae, the new Vatican bioethics document issued by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF) with the approval of Pope Benedict XVI, "accords the dignity of a person to the first cell that results from fertilization of an egg by a sperm."
Against this, Neaves reminds us that:
(1) in 1974 the same CDF said that it is not within the competence of human knowledge to determine when God infuses an immortal soul into a developing person;
(2) this built on the position of St. Thomas Aquinas eight centuries ago that it was the embryo's physical development that built a suitable home for the soul; and
(3) around the same time Dante conveyed the contemporary Catholic opinion that ensoulment could not take place until the embryo developed a functioning brain.
Neaves also raises two other, more contemporary challenges to making fertilization the moment of conception or personhood.
One is that a substantial number of fertilized eggs do not become pregnancies: "in many (and probably most) instances, the single cell resulting from fertilization of an egg by a sperm perishes in the woman’s reproductive tract and never implants in the uterus. Only after implantation does a birthed baby become highly probable. Would God have ordained that most people should die in the first two weeks of existence, long before seeing the light of day?"
A second issue is that sometimes two separately conceived fraternal twins fuse in the mother's reproductive tract and merge into a single embryo that comes to term. If fertilization is the first moment of personhood, how do the two separately conceived persons become one person?
To address these problems, and to reaffirm the insights of Aquinas, Dante and the CDF in 1974, Neaves likes a better option: "An alternative point of view to the Vatican’s, embraced by many Christians, is that personhood occurs after successful implantation in the mother’s uterus, when individual ontological identity is finally established."
This would obviate several positions that Dignitas Personae is forced to take by defining the start of personhood too soon in the reproductive process: "In the alternative moral framework, taking a pill to prevent the products of fertilization from implanting in a uterus is morally acceptable. Using in vitro fertilization to complete the family circle of couples otherwise unable to have children is an unmitigated good. Encouraging infertile couples with defective gametes to adopt already-produced embryos that will otherwise be discarded is a laudable objective. And using embryonic stem cells to seek cures becomes a worthy means of fulfilling the biblical mandate to heal the sick."
Three letters to the editor in the January 23rd NCR expanded on Neaves' concerns.
Bob Fehribach noted a different quandary in the case of identical twins: "In this situation, the developing embryo splits into two identical embryos. If personhood is determined at the time of fertilization, a similar question arises of how one person becomes two people."
Br. Finbar McMullen, FSC, quoting from Bernard Lee's The Future Church of 140 B.C.E.: A Hidden Revolution, cited two more examples from church history:
“The catechism of the Council of Trent holds that through miraculous intervention the human soul was joined to the matter from the first instance in the case of Jesus. Nobody can doubt that this was something new and an admirable work of the Holy Spirit, since in the natural order nobody can be informed by a human soul except after the prescribed space of time.” The implication is that for the rest of us, "the prescribed space of time" is some time after fertilization.
“The Holy Office declared in 1713 that a fetus can be baptized ‘if there is reasonable foundation for admitting that the fetus is animated by a rational soul. If, however, there is no reasonable foundation, it may by no means be baptized.’ ” The implication is that there is some period of time when the fetus is not animated by a rational soul.
Lucille Oliver voices the most extreme departure from the Vatican position: "A woman’s fertilized egg is no more a human than a walnut tree. Both have the potential of their God-given destinies, but the tree is dependent on proper earth care and nurturing. The egg-turned-fetus will live in symbiosis with the mother for six to seven months before it is able to live, even with help, outside the mother’s womb. At that point, it is a human being, not before." While equating viability with the beginning of human life moves the event later than Aquinas and the other commentators would, there is nothing in Christian or Jewish scripture that rules out Oliver's view.
Meanwhile, a February 2nd article on the NCR website reported that at a symposium on January 29th Leslie Woodcock Tentler, a professor of American Catholic history at the Catholic University of America, said the dominant approach of the current U.S. bishops on the abortion issue was out of character with their advocacy of social justice positions in the past, including positions on sexual ethics.
As background, the article says, Tentler listed several positions of "the 1919 'Bishops’ Program for Social Reconstruction,' the first statement issued by the then newly formed National Catholic War Council, the original organization of what is now the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops." She said the statement was in many ways a charter for what became FDR's New Deal. Of the eight provisions Tentler cited, not one mentioned the evil of abortion.
Even when the bishops did get around to a sexual ethics concern, their focus was on birth control, which some of them considered a graver sin than abortion. But given the political position of the Catholic church at the time, the bishops never took the position that the Catholic opposition to birth control should be written into U.S. law. The NCR article continued:
"'Anti-Catholicism was still a powerful emotion in American culture,' and the bishops had decided that in any battle against contraception they needed to have non-Catholic allies and needed to frame the public argument in ways that 'were not specifically religious,' she said. 'Among those nonreligious arguments was the family wage, a centerpiece of the 1919 bishops’ program. A truly just society, according to the bishops, is one that pays male workers enough to support a large family in comfort and security. An unjust society pays poverty wages, forces married women into the workforce and tells the poor to avoid having children.'
"She said the bishops eventually lost their fight against liberalized legal access to contraception, but her point was to highlight the difference between how that struggle was waged and how some bishops in recent years have been waging the fight against legalized abortion.
"'They consistently framed the debate in terms of values that nearly all Americans shared.'"
This echoes the theme of several Catholic Democrats, who argued during the last election that persuasion and cooperation with other people of good will would go much farther toward reducing the number of abortions in this country than trying to impose the official Catholic position as a matter of U.S. law.
The Vatican and the U.S. bishops have yet to address any of these questions successfully. They need to--before trying to impose Catholic abortion strictures on a society that includes believers and non-believers with multiple convictions on when life begins and when abortion should be banned.
Several challenge the official church position that conception occurs and human life begins the instant a sperm fertilizes an ovum. Another charges that the U.S. bishops departed from their own long tradition of social justice leadership by saying so often that abortion is the most serious social evil in U.S. society.
In the December 26th NCR, William B. Neaves, president and CEO of the Stowers Institute for Medical Research in Kansas City, Mo., asked simply, When does a person become a person?
His starting point is that Dignitas Personae, the new Vatican bioethics document issued by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF) with the approval of Pope Benedict XVI, "accords the dignity of a person to the first cell that results from fertilization of an egg by a sperm."
Against this, Neaves reminds us that:
(1) in 1974 the same CDF said that it is not within the competence of human knowledge to determine when God infuses an immortal soul into a developing person;
(2) this built on the position of St. Thomas Aquinas eight centuries ago that it was the embryo's physical development that built a suitable home for the soul; and
(3) around the same time Dante conveyed the contemporary Catholic opinion that ensoulment could not take place until the embryo developed a functioning brain.
Neaves also raises two other, more contemporary challenges to making fertilization the moment of conception or personhood.
One is that a substantial number of fertilized eggs do not become pregnancies: "in many (and probably most) instances, the single cell resulting from fertilization of an egg by a sperm perishes in the woman’s reproductive tract and never implants in the uterus. Only after implantation does a birthed baby become highly probable. Would God have ordained that most people should die in the first two weeks of existence, long before seeing the light of day?"
A second issue is that sometimes two separately conceived fraternal twins fuse in the mother's reproductive tract and merge into a single embryo that comes to term. If fertilization is the first moment of personhood, how do the two separately conceived persons become one person?
To address these problems, and to reaffirm the insights of Aquinas, Dante and the CDF in 1974, Neaves likes a better option: "An alternative point of view to the Vatican’s, embraced by many Christians, is that personhood occurs after successful implantation in the mother’s uterus, when individual ontological identity is finally established."
This would obviate several positions that Dignitas Personae is forced to take by defining the start of personhood too soon in the reproductive process: "In the alternative moral framework, taking a pill to prevent the products of fertilization from implanting in a uterus is morally acceptable. Using in vitro fertilization to complete the family circle of couples otherwise unable to have children is an unmitigated good. Encouraging infertile couples with defective gametes to adopt already-produced embryos that will otherwise be discarded is a laudable objective. And using embryonic stem cells to seek cures becomes a worthy means of fulfilling the biblical mandate to heal the sick."
Three letters to the editor in the January 23rd NCR expanded on Neaves' concerns.
Bob Fehribach noted a different quandary in the case of identical twins: "In this situation, the developing embryo splits into two identical embryos. If personhood is determined at the time of fertilization, a similar question arises of how one person becomes two people."
Br. Finbar McMullen, FSC, quoting from Bernard Lee's The Future Church of 140 B.C.E.: A Hidden Revolution, cited two more examples from church history:
“The catechism of the Council of Trent holds that through miraculous intervention the human soul was joined to the matter from the first instance in the case of Jesus. Nobody can doubt that this was something new and an admirable work of the Holy Spirit, since in the natural order nobody can be informed by a human soul except after the prescribed space of time.” The implication is that for the rest of us, "the prescribed space of time" is some time after fertilization.
“The Holy Office declared in 1713 that a fetus can be baptized ‘if there is reasonable foundation for admitting that the fetus is animated by a rational soul. If, however, there is no reasonable foundation, it may by no means be baptized.’ ” The implication is that there is some period of time when the fetus is not animated by a rational soul.
Lucille Oliver voices the most extreme departure from the Vatican position: "A woman’s fertilized egg is no more a human than a walnut tree. Both have the potential of their God-given destinies, but the tree is dependent on proper earth care and nurturing. The egg-turned-fetus will live in symbiosis with the mother for six to seven months before it is able to live, even with help, outside the mother’s womb. At that point, it is a human being, not before." While equating viability with the beginning of human life moves the event later than Aquinas and the other commentators would, there is nothing in Christian or Jewish scripture that rules out Oliver's view.
Meanwhile, a February 2nd article on the NCR website reported that at a symposium on January 29th Leslie Woodcock Tentler, a professor of American Catholic history at the Catholic University of America, said the dominant approach of the current U.S. bishops on the abortion issue was out of character with their advocacy of social justice positions in the past, including positions on sexual ethics.
As background, the article says, Tentler listed several positions of "the 1919 'Bishops’ Program for Social Reconstruction,' the first statement issued by the then newly formed National Catholic War Council, the original organization of what is now the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops." She said the statement was in many ways a charter for what became FDR's New Deal. Of the eight provisions Tentler cited, not one mentioned the evil of abortion.
Even when the bishops did get around to a sexual ethics concern, their focus was on birth control, which some of them considered a graver sin than abortion. But given the political position of the Catholic church at the time, the bishops never took the position that the Catholic opposition to birth control should be written into U.S. law. The NCR article continued:
"'Anti-Catholicism was still a powerful emotion in American culture,' and the bishops had decided that in any battle against contraception they needed to have non-Catholic allies and needed to frame the public argument in ways that 'were not specifically religious,' she said. 'Among those nonreligious arguments was the family wage, a centerpiece of the 1919 bishops’ program. A truly just society, according to the bishops, is one that pays male workers enough to support a large family in comfort and security. An unjust society pays poverty wages, forces married women into the workforce and tells the poor to avoid having children.'
"She said the bishops eventually lost their fight against liberalized legal access to contraception, but her point was to highlight the difference between how that struggle was waged and how some bishops in recent years have been waging the fight against legalized abortion.
"'They consistently framed the debate in terms of values that nearly all Americans shared.'"
This echoes the theme of several Catholic Democrats, who argued during the last election that persuasion and cooperation with other people of good will would go much farther toward reducing the number of abortions in this country than trying to impose the official Catholic position as a matter of U.S. law.
The Vatican and the U.S. bishops have yet to address any of these questions successfully. They need to--before trying to impose Catholic abortion strictures on a society that includes believers and non-believers with multiple convictions on when life begins and when abortion should be banned.
German Jews Know Vatican II Requires All Catholics to Repent of the Holocaust
Reuters reports that Germany's Central Council of Jews sees yesterday's Vatican statement that Catholic traditionalists must explicitly accept all of Vatican II--including its rejection of anti-Semitism and persecution of Jews as Christ-killers or God-killers--as a direct result of Chancellor Angela Merkel's criticism of the pope and an affirmation that the pope himself will adhere to Vatican II. The Reuters article follows:
Germany's Central Council of Jews welcomed the Vatican's decision to order a traditionalist bishop who denies the Holocaust to recant Wednesday, saying it could lead to a resumption of ties with the Catholic Church.
Charlotte Knobloch, president of the Council of Jews, said the Vatican's move was a positive signal and a reaction to German Chancellor Angela Merkel's demand for clarification after Pope Benedict sparked outrage over his rehabilitation of the bishop.
"It is a first step which could lead to a resumption of dialogue with the Catholic Church," said Knobloch in a statement which struck a conciliatory tone after she said last week she was breaking off ties with the Catholic church.
She had been angered by the German pope's rehabilitation of Bishop Richard Williamson, who denies the extent of the Holocaust in which Nazis killed 6 million Jews, and that of three other members of the ultra-traditional Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX).
Knobloch also welcomed the Vatican's statement earlier that SSPX must accept all the teachings of the Second Vatican Council, which urged respect for Judaism and other religions.
"That would mean the brotherhood would have to publicly retract their statements that Jewish citizens are murders of God, and to firmly condemn every form of Holocaust denial," Knobloch said.
Germany's Central Council of Jews welcomed the Vatican's decision to order a traditionalist bishop who denies the Holocaust to recant Wednesday, saying it could lead to a resumption of ties with the Catholic Church.
Charlotte Knobloch, president of the Council of Jews, said the Vatican's move was a positive signal and a reaction to German Chancellor Angela Merkel's demand for clarification after Pope Benedict sparked outrage over his rehabilitation of the bishop.
"It is a first step which could lead to a resumption of dialogue with the Catholic Church," said Knobloch in a statement which struck a conciliatory tone after she said last week she was breaking off ties with the Catholic church.
She had been angered by the German pope's rehabilitation of Bishop Richard Williamson, who denies the extent of the Holocaust in which Nazis killed 6 million Jews, and that of three other members of the ultra-traditional Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX).
Knobloch also welcomed the Vatican's statement earlier that SSPX must accept all the teachings of the Second Vatican Council, which urged respect for Judaism and other religions.
"That would mean the brotherhood would have to publicly retract their statements that Jewish citizens are murders of God, and to firmly condemn every form of Holocaust denial," Knobloch said.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)