Friday, August 28, 2009

Obama Letting Corps of Engineers Drown New Orleans Again, Experts and Locals Say

Entertainer Harry Schearer, who has spent enough time in New Orleans since Katrina to consider it his adopted home, says in a CNN commentary that experts believe the Army Corps of Engineers is repeating the same mistakes that allowed their levee system to fail in more than 50 locations--and that like George W. Bush, President Obama is doing nothing to stop them. Excerpts from the commentary:

New Orleans, hit so hard by what so many (including President Obama in his Sunday interview with the local newspaper) still see fit to describe, mistakenly, as a natural disaster, is making remarkable progress, while the agency that so disastrously failed at building a protective system mandated by Congress -- the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers -- may be making some of the same mistakes in rebuilding that system. And the White House, for the second consecutive administration, seems not to care.

Me? I'm a humorist, a comic actor, a sometime musician-filmmaker-novelist-blogger. What the hell do I know about what happened to the city I love?

Since the levees collapsed, I've been reading the local newspaper, the Times-Picayune, watching and listening to the local media, which, post-disaster, have rediscovered their mission to make local news more than a recitation of the previous day's murders, car crashes and celebrity misbehaviors.

While the national media packed up and moved away after the initial orgasm of anger at FEMA, the local media reported something remarkable: The Corps was claiming that the flooding was due to the "overtopping" of its levees and floodwalls, while two teams of pro-bono forensic investigators were finding evidence that no overtopping had occurred.

As the Corps started denigrating these investigators, they kept digging, and kept coming up with the real story, available now for all to see (though all too few have) as the ILIT report from the University of California at Berkeley and the Team Louisiana report from Louisiana State University.

Their conclusions: The "hurricane protection system" built by the Corps had serious design and construction flaws, baked into the system over 40 years under administrations of both parties, that caused catastrophic failure in more than 50 locations under storm surge conditions markedly less than the system was advertised to withstand.

You and I, federal taxpayers, had paid to flood New Orleans.

Since the Obama administration took office, the Corps has: announced that one part of the new "system" will be built using a "technically not superior" solution, because of funding problems; and, defying a Congressional mandate, delivered a report supposed to offer a post-2011 plan for so-called Category 5 storm protection 20 months late and lacking a specific plan, offering only a menu of possible options. It's almost as if the Corps is inviting someone else to do the job.

Someone else can. A New Orleans architect, David Waggonner, has been convening a group of local architects and planners and engineers and their Dutch colleagues to mine the eight centuries of collective wisdom of the Netherlands about the challenge of living with water.

The resulting plans, published as the "Dutch dialogues," make for inspiring and depressing reading; inspiring because they offer a vision of a city that has stopped fighting a war against water and has learned to use water both to enhance value and to enhance safety, depressing because there is so clearly no federal impetus, from the president on down, to embrace such a new approach.

President Obama, who has mainly limited his comments about New Orleans to feel-good boilerplate, did pledge to make good on President Bush's promise on that eerie, floodlit night in a deserted Jackson Square in 2005, to rebuild New Orleans better and stronger. But he has yet to actively intervene to make sure New Orleans gets state-of-the-art flood protection and robust and timely coastal wetland reconstruction. Like President Bush, President Obama so far seems to be acting as if just saying it makes it so.


Sandy Rosenthal said...

My colleague and I accompanied David Waggonner to Holland this past May and we created a 7-minute video on how the Dutch protect their people.

You can watch it using this link:

Sandy Rosenthal, wife, mother, New Orleans resident and founder of

New Orleans Ladder said...

Hey Gerald, thank you for this post.
Down here we call such media laziness: "Katrina Shorthand".
It is like clearing a Yeast Infection.

Harry spoke of this at his Keynote Address to the Rising Tide Nola Bloggers Conference recently in New Orleans.
Also, Harry did an excellent frightening interview with Maria Garzino, the Corps Engineer who blew the whistle on our new post-flood expensive worthless pumps.

You may know of
And, needless to say we hung you onto today's Ladder.
Battling this Katrina Shorthand in the Media is getting harder than many would think. It is everywhere.

Thanks again,
Editilla~New Orleans Ladder